| Platinum | Basta Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Bettola |
| Silver | Tommy's Pizza Too |
| Bronze | Cucina Rustica |
| Top Pick | Caffe Itri |
| Top Pick | Culinary Affair |
| Top Pick | Lou Umberto's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Macera's |
| Top Pick | Marchetti's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Big Cheese |